Amy Allen has her hands full when there’s a family wedding in town, especially when she ends up with unexpected house guests. As she and her sister, Tracy, prepare for the gatherings that lead up to the big day, Selene Stanton arrives, asking about an Egyptian cat statue that her adventure loving ancestor gave to Grandma Pearl many years ago. She is desperate to send the statue back to Egypt to stop the bad luck she believes has been plaguing her family.

Though Amy doesn’t believe in bad luck, she searches for the statue and finds it, only to have it disappear again! When others come out of the woodwork looking for the relic, Amy’s list of suspects grows. Will she be able to find the culprit and unlock the secrets of the mysterious statue’s past and return it to its rightful owner, whoever that may be?

Amy Allen heads out for a night of fun to watch her sister, Tracy, participate in a river cruise mystery dinner theater production. But things take a shocking turn during the show when Tracy is kidnapped for real! Amy is both relieved and baffled a few hours later when Tracy calls and reveals that those who abducted her left her behind. Amy and Tracy wonder if she was simply at the wrong place at the wrong time. But then who was the true target? And what were they hoping to accomplish?

Meanwhile, Amy is becoming more and more interested in rekindling her romance with her high school sweetheart, Miles Anderson. But is she truly ready to put her heart on the line? Perhaps more important, are her kids, Matt and Jana, ready to have a father figure in their lives—even one who is the father of their closest friends? Amy will need to trust that God will reveal His plans for her in His time.

Among old photos from Grandma Pearl’s attic, Amy Allen- Anderson and her sister, Tracy Doyle, find an offer their parents signed to buy a lake house in Centerville, Iowa. Shockingly, the document is dated the day before their parents died in a car accident. The sisters always wondered why their parents were in that area on that fateful day. If they were looking at the property, why didn’t they mention it to the family?

Meanwhile, Amy has hired a contractor to secretly remodel part of their home for Miles, so it seems like the perfect time to take a vacation and visit the mysterious lake house. But what they discover there is even more baffling. Can the sisters follow the clues to a decades-old scavenger hunt and uncover the truth that will bring them not only closure on their parents’ tragic deaths, but perhaps a final gift from them after all this time?